Psychology of Actions: The 5 Laws of Self-Talk Change

A Step-by-Step Guide to Rewriting Your Inner Dialogue

In my previous article, 'Psychology of Actions: Dialogues Within,' we explored the mechanics of self-talk, how it forms, and how it reinforces itself over time. This article briefly recaps the previous article before it builds on that. In case you want a deeper understanding, I have linked the last article here:

• Dialogues Within

This article also recaps and builds on foundational ideas based on System 1 and System 2 Thinking. You can check those articles here:

• The System 1 and System 2 Thinking

• System 1, System 2, and the Process of Change for Personal Development

• Recognizing which System is the dominant

Now, let's dive in.

---

Introduction

The conversations we have with ourselves shape our entire reality. From trivial decisions to life-changing moments, our Self-Talk can hold the power to propel us forward. Yet, for many, Self-Talk becomes a constant augmentor of limiting beliefs and negativity. It turns into an unrelenting voice that criticizes, doubts and discourages.

The thing is, most of our Self-Talk happens on autopilot, beneath our awareness. Without even realizing it, we fall into patterns of thinking that reinforce over time. It doesn't matter whether the thinking pattern reinforces a positive, limiting, or negative belief. The bottom line is that repeated thinking patterns become ingrained.

This brings us to the central idea: Our Self-Talk patterns are primarily a product of System 1 thinking, the part of our brain that handles automatic, instinctive responses.

Self-Talk and System 1

Think of System 1 as the autopilot of your brain. It’s fast, impulsive, and emotional. It’s where habits, beliefs, and yes, even your self-talk reside. After being repeated countless times, your self-talk becomes a part of your System 1 Thinking.

This is where the concept of loops comes in. Since System 1 operates on repetition, everything non-cognitive that is a part of it tends to follow a loop. Now, a loop is a cycle that keeps spinning unless we actively intervene through our System 2 Thinking. Self-talk is no different. It forms through repeated thoughts and emotions, which solidify into beliefs. Once formed, these beliefs then reinforce themselves through our actions and feelings.

Let’s recap the two main loops that shape self-talk:

The Formation Loop

This is the natural way self-talk is formed. It happens so subtly that we don’t even notice it unfolding.

Here’s how it works:

1. Observe: We experience something, like a situation, a challenge, or an interaction.

2. Absorb: We interpret that experience, usually through past beliefs or emotions.

3. Feel: Emotions get attached to that interpretation, whether it’s fear, excitement, or doubt.

4. Loosely Belief: We begin to form a loose belief based on that feeling, though it’s not fully solidified yet.

5. Self-Talk Formation: Our self-talk starts to align with this new belief, whether it's about avoiding a challenge or pursuing an opportunity.

The Reinforcement Loop

Once the belief forms, it doesn’t just sit passively in the background. It reinforces itself, digging deeper into our mind through repetition:

1. Trigger: Something happens and it activates the loose belief (e.g., a tough situation).

2. Process via Loose Belief: Our belief kicks in, guiding how we interpret what’s happening.

3. Feeling Reinforcement: The emotions tied to that belief intensify.

4. Belief Reinforcement: The belief becomes even stronger, embedding itself further into our mindset.

5. Self-Talk Reinforcement: Our self-talk follows suit, repeating the cycle all over again and again...

So, self-talk, like everything that's a part of our System 1, forms after countless repetitions and follows these loops. The good news? Once you understand how these loops work, you can recognize the patterns and then, rewrite them.

But before we get there let's first understand what we are dealing with.

---

Limiting and Negative Self-Talk

What is it?

Self-talk isn’t always your best friend. In fact, for many of us, it's our inner critic, the voice that loves to remind us of our shortcomings. This voice is either Limiting or Negative Self-Talk. It’s the self-sabotaging beliefs that hold us back. It says things such as:

Limiting Self-Talk:

1. Fear of Failure: "I'm afraid I won't succeed."

2. Self-Doubt: "I don't think I'm good enough."

3. Perfectionism: "I have to be perfect at everything."

4. Lack of Confidence: "I'm not capable of doing this."

5. Negative Self-Comparison: "I'm not as good as them."

6. Focus on Limitations: "I'm not good at math."

7. Fear of Rejection: "People won't like me."

8. Pessimism: "Nothing good ever happens to me."

9. Avoiding Challenges: "I'm not up to the task."

10. Feeling Helpless: "I can't change anything."

Negative Self-Talk:

1. Catastrophizing: "If I make a mistake, it'll be a disaster."

2. Overgeneralization: "I'm always clumsy."

3. Personalization: "Everything bad that happens is my fault."

4. Jumping to Conclusions: "They don't like me because I'm not interesting."

5. Filtering: "I'm such a failure, nothing good will ever happen to me."

6. Polarized Thinking: "It's either perfect or a complete disaster."

7. Should Statements: "I should be better at this."

8. Labeling: "I'm so stupid."

9. Disqualifying the Positive: "That was just luck, it doesn't count."

10. Mind Reading: "They think I'm boring."

This limiting or negative self-talk doesn’t just pop up randomly. It’s the product of deeply ingrained beliefs built over time through repeated thoughts and experiences. You might not even realize how much power these thoughts hold, but over time, they can shape how you see yourself and the world around you.

For instance, imagine you’ve had a few failures in the past, maybe with a project at work or a personal goal. Each time you faced a setback, your mind likely absorbed that experience and attached a negative emotion to it, such as disappointment, frustration, or even shame. Over time, these emotions formed a belief: “I’m just not good enough at this.” Eventually, this belief became a part of your self-talk: every time a similar challenge appeared, that voice immediately chimed in, “You can’t do it.”

Limiting and Negative self-talk can be about anything—from your abilities, and appearance, to even your worth as a person. But, the key point is this: just as limiting or negative self-talk was formed through repetition, it can be rewritten through deliberate effort and awareness.

---

Rewriting the Self-Talk

Now that we understand limiting and negative self-talk, let’s explore how to rewrite it. Just like the negative self-talk loops formed through repetition, we can intentionally rewrite our self-talk with new, empowering narratives.

But before we dive into that, let’s recap two essential aspects of personal development that will help guide this process:

Now, let’s apply these aspects to Self-Talk.

Step 1: Recognizing our Automatic Self-Talk that isn’t Serving Us

The first step in rewriting self-talk is recognizing the automatic thoughts and responses deeply embedded in our System 1 thinking. These are fast, impulsive thoughts that occur beneath our awareness—often negative or limiting—and have been reinforced over time. Without recognizing them, we’re unable to change them.

Now, I’m sharing a questionnaire to make it easy to recognize the need to change your Self-Talk. This questionnaire works because of two reasons:

1. Self-Reflection: The questionnaire prompts you, the reader, to reflect on your current self-talk, helping you become aware of specific negative patterns.

2. Actionable Insight: Your answers to the questions will help you identify specific triggers, emotions, and beliefs associated with your self-talk, leading to a more concrete recognition of the need for change.

So, without further ado, here's the questionnaire.

Questionnaire to Recognize the Need for Self-Talk Change

1. Awareness of Trigger:

   • When you face a challenge or setback, what are the first thoughts that come to mind?

   • Do you notice recurring phrases or themes in your internal dialogue during stressful situations?

2. Interpretation:

   • How do you typically interpret mistakes or failures? Do you tend to blame yourself or others?

   • What emotional tone does your self-talk take when something goes wrong (e.g., harsh, critical, supportive)?

3. Attaching Feelings and Emotions:

   • What feelings do you commonly associate with your self-talk (e.g., frustration, guilt, anxiety)?

   • Do you find your self-talk intensifies your emotional reactions to situations?

4. Adopting Beliefs:

   • Do your self-talk patterns reinforce any beliefs about your abilities, worth, or potential? Are these beliefs positive or negative?

   • How do you feel about yourself after engaging in self-talk? Do you notice a difference in confidence or motivation?

5. Reinforcement:

   • Do these internal conversations tend to repeat themselves across different scenarios?

   • How often do you engage in negative self-talk compared to positive self-talk?

6. Overall Need for Change:

   • How satisfied are you with your current self-talk? Do you believe it helps or hinders your progress?

   • If you were to change one aspect of your self-talk, what would it be?

After completing the questionnaire, the need for change should feel natural, preparing you for the next step of Awareness to engage System 2 Thinking.

Step 2: Awareness to Engage System 2 Thinking

Once we’ve recognized the automatic self-talk responses that are not serving us, the next step is engaging System 2—the more deliberate, conscious part of our thinking. This is where the real work begins. By intentionally activating System 2, we can override the negative loops in System 1 and begin rewriting our self-talk with new, positive beliefs.

Here, I have come up with the 5 Laws of Self-talk change. The structure of these laws emphasizes clarity, actionability, and universality. Each law can be applied consistently to improve self-talk.

5 Laws of Self-Talk Change

Law 1: Recognize the Trigger

"You can't change what you don't notice."

• Purpose: To bring awareness to the moments when negative self-talk begins.

• Explanation: Self-talk starts with a cue—whether it’s a situation, a thought, or a feeling. The first step toward changing your self-talk is recognizing when it’s happening.

• Action: Pay attention to moments that trigger self-talk, whether it’s stress, fear, or insecurity. By identifying these triggers, you gain control over how you respond.

Law 2: Reframe the Interpretation

"Change the story, change the outcome."

• Purpose: To shift the interpretation of experiences or thoughts into something constructive.

• Explanation: Our minds are constantly interpreting events, and this interpretation fuels our self-talk. The second law is to deliberately reframe the situation in a way that promotes positive dialogue instead of reinforcing negativity.

• Action: When faced with negative self-talk, ask yourself: “Is this interpretation helping me?” Shift your perspective from criticism to learning and growth.

Law 3: Attach Positive Emotions

"Emotion is the glue of belief."

• Purpose: To actively infuse positive emotions into the new self-talk.

• Explanation: Emotions are the driving force behind how deeply we believe in our self-talk. By deliberately associating positive feelings with new self-talk, you make it more impactful and memorable.

• Action: When you craft new self-talk, make it emotionally resonant. Imagine how it feels to succeed, to overcome, to grow, and to attach that feeling to your new self-talk phrases.

Law 4: Adopt Empowering Beliefs

"You become what you repeatedly tell yourself."

• Purpose: To intentionally form new beliefs based on positive self-talk.

• Explanation: Self-talk influences your beliefs over time. To truly change, you must adopt empowering beliefs that reflect the person you wish to become, instead of reinforcing old limiting beliefs.

• Action: Choose self-talk that aligns with your goals and values. Consciously affirm beliefs that empower you, even if they feel unnatural in the beginning.

Law 5: Repeat to Reinforce

"Consistency turns self-talk into reality."

• Purpose: To repeat positive self-talk until it replaces the automatic System 1 self-talk and becomes your default inner dialogue.

• Explanation: Just as negative self-talk forms through repetition, so does positive self-talk. The more you repeat new patterns, the stronger they become, eventually overriding old habits.

• Action: Practice your new self-talk consistently. When you catch your negative self-talk, immediately replace it with the positive dialogue you've chosen.

Each of these laws is tied to an actionable behavior that you can apply immediately. They make it easy to understand how to change self-talk in practical, incremental steps. They also give you the feeling of efficacy over your self-talk, reinforcing your sense of agency.

---

Concluding Thoughts

Rewriting your self-talk is not an overnight transformation. It’s a deliberate process that requires awareness, effort, and, above all, patience. Just as negative and limiting beliefs form over time, positive and empowering beliefs take time to take root. But the beauty of this journey is that with each small step, you gain more control over your internal dialogue. And with that control comes a shift in how you view yourself.

You can gain an understanding of how your self-talk operates—through the Formation and Reinforcement Loops—and recognize the automatic, System 1-driven responses that no longer serve you. Armed with the 5 Laws of Self-Talk Change, you now have the tools to break free from the old loops and create new, positive ones.

Remember, this process starts with small, intentional changes. The more you apply these laws and engage your System 2 thinking, the more your self-talk will align with where you want to be. It’s not about perfection but progress. And, as you rewrite the dialogues within, you’ll discover that you have the power to shape your thoughts, actions, and ultimately, your reality.

So, take a deep breath, listen to your inner dialogue, and begin to rewrite it—one empowering thought at a time.

---

That’s all for this week. If you like this article, please share it. And, if you have not subscribed yet, please do and join me on this fascinating journey of intentional change.

Stay genuine! Stay authentic!

Nik Pathran

---

PS: I appreciate you reading. Thanks to the new subscribers! ✌

---